Been reading Woody Paige since I was a teen. Over the past 35 years,. Woody has been part of my reading life. Still remember sitting in my high school journalism class at Denver South, reading Woody.
Sometimes he made me laugh.
And sometimes he left me trying to figure out what the hell he was talking about.
Still trying to understand Woody, who has recently been at his most baffling.
Woody, the Denver Post columnist and ESPN personality, is intent on comparing Tim Tebow to John Elway.
“He has that same aura Elway had as a rookie,” Woody recently wrote.
And that might be true. Tebow might have the same aura.
Problem is, he doesn’t have the same arm. Elway was a once-in-a-lifetime quarterback, a once-in-a-lifetime talent, a once-in-a-lifetime personality.
And, as I’ve said before, a once-in-a-lifetime quarterback comes around, yes, once in a lifetime. It’s ridiculous and unfair and silly to compare Tebow to Elway.
Aura doesn’t have much to do with solving NFL defenses.
Elway was the No. 1 pick in the NFL draft and one of the best QB prospects ever.
Tebow was the No. 25 pick in the NFL draft and generally considered a reach. Coach Josh McDaniels is, like Paige, smitten with Tebow. We’ll soon see if McDaniels is cluelessly smitten. Tebow is a run-first quarterback, and run-first quarterbacks don’t succeed in the NFL.
Of course, Tebow could become the pioneer.
There is no position in sport more difficult to play than NFL quarterback. There is no position in sport more difficult to predict. Ryan Leaf was, on paper, the best quarterback prospect since Elway, and we all know how Leaf turned out.
Tebow has a chance. He could surprise me and many others and become a quality NFL starter.
Tebow never will become another Elway. Never. Ever. It will not happen.
Tebow won’t come close to becoming another Elway.
And you can count on that.
Here’s Woody’s look at Tebow:
http://www.denverpost.com/broncos/ci_14980266?obref=obinsite
And here’s Dave Krieger’s more clear-eyed look at Tebow (and Elway):
http://www.denverpost.com/krieger/ci_15106536