Don’t worry. I have an answer to the question:
No.
Most coaches and most players embrace the chance to explain their decisions and actions. They can tell fans why they kicked a field goal instead of going for a touchdown or why they made a substitution when they did or why they ran out-of-bounds or why they took a swing at that curveball or …
You get the picture. Reporters offer a means for coaches and athletes to explain themselves, and there’s no better time for explaining than after a loss. Silence solves nothing.
Many, maybe most, fans misunderstand the relationship coaches and athletes have with reporters. Yes, it’s sometimes confrontational and tense, but most of the time it’s friendly. And the anger that does occasionally crash into the relationship usually goes away. Coaches and athletes understand that reporters have a job to do and coaches and athletes also understand that this job usually benefits them.
Here’s an example of what I’m talking about:
The Denver Broncos cut Maurice Clarett in late August of 2005. Clarett ranked alongside Dale Carter and Daryl (the IHOP Avenger) Gardener as Shanahan’s worst decisions. It was an embarrassing day for Shanahan and the franchise.
Shanahan faced a horde of reporters and put his spin on Clarett’s departure. The decision, he said, said more about the Broncos depth than said about Clarett’s lack of effort and talent.
Later, Shanahan met with several individual reporters to explain why he took a chance on Clarett. Shanahan didn’t run from reporters. He knew it was a good time for damage control.
He talked with me one-on-one for several minutes. I brought up Carter and Gardener.
And he said this:
“That’s football. That’s life,” he said of his mistakes. “I had a number of guys on the Super Bowl teams that people told me, hey, don’t take a chance on them. A few of those guys were slam-dunk nos, and they performed well for us. They helped us win a couple Super Bowls.”
I made a point.
He made a counter-point. His explanation ran in The Gazette for thousands of fans to consider.
That’s how the business works.
I’m interested in your views on this subject, which has been in the minds of Air Force fans recently after the Falcons greatly reduced reporters’ access to football players.
COMING TOMORROW: A look back at a post-game interview with a seemingly ticked off John Elway.